So, I decided that with each video review, I'm going to write a review to go along with it. That way, I'll produce a more thorough review and have fuller posts! Perfect!
So, The Diviners. It was published in late 2012, and its critical reception was largely favorable. This book was written by Libba Bray, who enjoyed commercial success with her A Great and Terrible Beauty series, and critical acclaim with her novel Going Bovine. The book follows a young woman, Evie O'Neil, during 1926.
Like Bray's protagonist of Terrible Beauty, Gemma Doyle, Evie O'Neil is a girl with special powers. She can psychically read objects. She has trouble keeping what she learns from this power a secret, however, and soon lands in hot water when she makes an accusation against a prominent citizen in the Ohio town where she resides. She's bustled off to live with her uncle in New York City. Her uncle, it so happens, owns and operates an occult museum.
“There is no greater power on this earth than story.” Will paced the length of the room. “People think boundaries and borders build nations. Nonsense—words do. Beliefs, declarations, constitutions—words. Stories. Myths. Lies. Promises. History.” Will grabbed the sheaf of newspaper clippings he kept in a stack on his desk. “This, and these”—he gestured to the library’s teeming shelves—“they’re a testament to the country’s rich supernatural history.”
Despite her own gifts, Evie is skeptical of the museum and her uncle at first. But when her uncle is called as a specialist during a murder investigation, she winds up falling down a supernatural rabbit hole.
“Naughty John, Naughty John, does his work with his apron on. Cuts your throat and takes your bones, sells 'em off for a coupla stones.”
I give the book three and a half stars. While it had fantastic elements, there were some strong weaknesses as well. In regards to the well done aspects, the book's setting is overwhelmingly the best part of the book. You can tell that Bray put in an enormous amount of research to get the right 20's atmosphere down. A lot of times, when reading historical fiction, the modern language and voice pull me out of the period. But, with The Diviners, every detail helps add to the jazz age allure.
The book also has a strong protagonist. Evie is a great character — a flapper, smart, sassy, and vivacious. She is always ready with a wisecrack.
“Your mother and I do not approve of drinking. Have you not heard of the Eighteenth Amendment?”
“Prohibition? I drink to its health whenever I can.”
Evangeline — a hilarious name for this skeptic character — dazzles brightly off the page, while still retaining emotional depth.
“She was tired of being told how it was by this generation, who’d botched things so badly. They’d sold their children a pack of lies: God and country. Love your parents. All is fair. And then they’d sent those boys, her brother, off to fight a great monster of a war that maimed and killed and destroyed whatever was inside them. Still they lied, expecting her to mouth the words and play along. Well, she wouldn’t. She knew now that the world was a long way from fair. She knew the monsters were real.”
Now, onto the stuff I didn't like so much. I think the book needs huge amounts of editing. The story follows two other characters, Memphis Campbell and Theta Knight. Three points of view were largely extraneous, I thought. The book would have been stronger with a good deal of extraneous storyline shaved off, and extra narrative perspectives don't make the cut.
Second, I thought the romance was bland! This isn't a critical failure on the book's part, or anything, but a compelling romance makes a golden story, in my opinion. I'm waiting to see how things unfold in the sequel in this regard.
So, that's that. I don't go into greater depth in my video, but there is the added bonus of facial expressions!
